How to Avoid Landlord and Tenant Disputes

Landlord and tenant disputes are one of the most stressful aspects of managing a rental property. They can arise at any stage of a tenancy, cost significant time and money, and strain what might otherwise be a positive relationship. With the right approach, many of the most common causes of tenant disputes can be avoided altogether.

Understanding what tends to trigger landlord and tenant disputes is a helpful first step. Many disagreements follow predictable patterns and knowing them in advance can help you put protections in place early.

Damp, mould, and outstanding maintenance problems are a frequent source of tenant disputes. Tenants have a legal right to live in a property that’s safe and in good repair, and delays in addressing concerns can quickly escalate into formal complaints.

Disagreements over property damage are among the most common landlord-tenant disputes. The difficulty often lies in establishing what damage occurred, when it happened, and who’s responsible. For more information, read our guide on who is responsible for accidental damage in a rental property.

Rent arrears and late payments represent some of the most frequent sources of conflict in landlord-tenant relationships. These disputes often stem from a breakdown in communication, temporary financial instability, or disagreements regarding payment timelines and responsibilities.

The line between fair wear and tear (such as worn carpets after several years of use) and actual damage (such as broken fixtures or stained walls) is a common grey area. Tenants may feel deductions from their deposit are unreasonable, while landlords may feel the property has been left in a worse condition than expected. A thorough inventory from the outset is one of the most effective ways to manage this.

When tenants sublet rooms or allow long-term occupants to move in without permission, this may breach the tenancy agreement. It can also affect the landlord’s legal obligations and, in some cases, their insurance cover. These situations are worth addressing early, before they develop into a more formal owner-tenant dispute.

If a tenancy agreement does not permit pets but a tenant keeps one, this can become a source of conflict. Under the Renters’ Rights Act, landlords are now required to provide a reasonable justification if they refuse a tenant’s request.

Disputes may also arise when a tenancy agreement’s terms haven’t been clearly communicated or followed by either party. A clear, well-drafted tenancy agreement helps set expectations from day one.

Dealing with difficult tenants is far easier when you’ve built a solid foundation at the start of the tenancy. Here are the key steps that can make a meaningful difference.

A solid referencing process typically includes credit checks, employment verification, previous landlord references, and Right to Rent checks, which are a legal requirement in England. Our guide on why tenant background checks are important explains what to look for.

A generic template downloaded from the internet may not cover everything you need. A well-drafted Assured Shorthold Tenancy (AST) agreement should set out both parties’ expectations clearly, including policies on pets, smoking, maintenance reporting timelines, and how and when rent should be paid.

Our guide on what to include in a tenancy agreement outlines the key areas to address.

A signed inventory is one of the most valuable documents a landlord can have. It should include dated photographs of every room, appliance, fixture, and any pre-existing marks or damage. Both parties should sign it at move-in and keep a copy. Without it, resolving disputes between landlords and tenants over deposit deductions becomes considerably harder.

Keeping all communications in writing throughout the tenancy. Email or a property management portal creates a clear record of what was agreed, requested, or reported and is easier to rely on if a dispute arises. Avoid informal text messages or phone calls if possible, as they can lead to misunderstandings.

Landlords in England are legally required to protect deposits in a government-approved scheme. Services such as the Tenancy Deposit Scheme protect the deposit and provide a dispute resolution service which can help avoid an owner-tenant dispute reaching the courts.

Looking for support as a landlord? Just Landlords can provide cover designed around the needs of residential landlords. Find out more about our landlord insurance cover options.

Even with solid preparation in place, disputes can still arise. If you need help, here’s a practical approach to follow.

Many disputes start with a misunderstanding. A calm, constructive conversation can sometimes resolve things quickly without formal action. Keep any follow-up in writing so there’s a record of what’s been discussed and agreed.

If direct communication doesn’t resolve the issue, tenant dispute resolution services and independent mediation can be a helpful middle step. ADR tends to be quicker, less formal, and significantly less costly than legal proceedings, and both parties retain more control over the resolution than they would in a court setting.

Throughout any dispute, keep detailed records of all communications, maintenance reports, payments, and relevant correspondence. Good record-keeping is one of the most practical things you can do when handling tenant disputes.

If other approaches haven’t worked, legal options may include debt recovery proceedings or applying to the courts for possession. Under the Renters’ Rights Act, Section 21 no-fault evictions have been abolished. Landlords seeking possession may now need to rely on a Section 8 notice, which applies where a tenant has breached the tenancy agreement. Specialist legal advice is strongly recommended before taking formal action.

Going back to the tenancy agreement may help to clarify what’s been agreed and provide a basis for resolving the issue. Both parties should agree to and sign any amendments.

An independent mediator can help both parties reach a resolution without the cost and delay of court proceedings. It’s often a more suitable route for resolving landlord and tenant disputes fairly and legally.

Where a dispute can’t be resolved informally, a Section 8 notice may be appropriate on specific fault-based grounds, such as significant rent arrears or other serious breaches of the tenancy agreement. Specialist legal advice should be sought before proceeding.

Key legislation includes the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which outlines a landlord’s duties around maintenance and repair, and the Renters’ Rights Act, which introduced significant changes to the landlord-tenant relationship. Understanding your obligations helps you act within the law and supports your position if a dispute escalates.

Managing multiple rental properties? Just Landlords can provide cover suited to landlords with larger portfolios. Find out more about our multiple property insurance options.

Choosing a specialist insurance provider is an important part of protecting your property and helping to give you peace of mind as a landlord. Here’s why many landlords choose Just Landlords:

• Rated Great on Trustpilot*, with over 1,000 reviews.
• Over 25 years of experience providing residential landlord insurance
• An in-house customer service and claims team based in Nottingham.
• Friendly support available by phone, LiveChat, or email.

*Correct as at June 2026

Please note that these frequently asked questions are not a substitute for the policy wording. For full terms and conditions, please see the policy documentation.

No. Section 21 no-fault evictions have been abolished under the Renters’ Rights Act. Landlords seeking possession should consider whether a Section 8 notice may apply, which allows for a fault-based eviction on specific grounds. Specialist legal advice is strongly recommended before serving any notice.

Yes, a landlord can take legal action where there are grounds to do so. This may include applying for a possession order or pursuing debt recovery. It’s generally a last resort, and it’s worth exploring mediation and other forms of tenant dispute resolution before taking that step.

Thorough screening and referencing before the tenancy begins is one of the most effective ways to reduce risk. A clear tenancy agreement and a detailed, signed inventory at move-in also provide important protection. Our guide on tenant background checks covers what to look for in more detail.

Mediation involves an independent third party who helps both parties work towards a resolution without going to court. It’s typically quicker, less formal, and less costly than legal proceedings, and both parties retain more control over the outcome.

It typically starts with direct, documented communication. If that doesn’t resolve things, ADR or mediation may be a suitable next step. Where those avenues have been exhausted, legal remedies may be considered. Keeping detailed records throughout is important, as documentation may be relied upon if the matter escalates.

Start with open communication, consider mediation or ADR, and seek specialist legal advice where needed. Reviewing the tenancy agreement together and keeping clear records at every stage are all part of resolving landlord and tenant disputes fairly and legally.

The sole purpose of this article is to provide guidance on the issues covered. This article is not intended to give legal advice, and, accordingly, it should not be relied upon. It should not be regarded as a comprehensive statement of the law and/or market practice in this area. We make no claims as to the completeness or accuracy of the information contained herein or in the links which were live at the date of publication. You should not act upon (or should refrain from acting upon) information in this publication without first seeking specific legal and/or specialist advice. Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited trading as Just Landlords accepts no liability for any inaccuracy, omission or mistake in this publication, nor will we be responsible for any loss which may be suffered as a result of any person relying on the information contained herein.